Hospital Discharge Rights: The CARE Act, Notices and Appeals

What a state CARE Act requires: name the caregiver, notify, then train

Every state-level CARE Act follows a similar framework. These laws require hospitals to ask the patient if they want to name a family caregiver in their medical record. This caregiver is not just an emergency contact. Instead, the named person is the hospital's point of contact for discharge planning and aftercare instructions.

The next requirement is notice. Once a caregiver is named, the hospital must inform this person when the patient is about to be discharged or transferred. This means you should not hear about discharge for the first time at the bedside or when a staff member wheels your parent to the curb.

Finally, these laws require the hospital to offer training. The caregiver must be shown how to perform any necessary medical tasks at home, such as wound care, injections, or medication management. This is not supposed to be a rushed conversation in the hallway. The law expects a demonstration and time for questions.

Keep reading: Getting Paid to Care: Inside Structured Family Caregiving

Which states have adopted one and what it does not reach

Most states have passed some form of the CARE Act. These include large states like California, New York, Texas, and Florida, as well as many others. In these states, hospitals are legally obligated to follow the steps: ask the patient to name a caregiver, notify that caregiver of discharge, and provide instruction.

However, not all states have adopted the CARE Act. In those states, hospitals may follow similar practices as a matter of policy, but caregivers have fewer legal protections. Even in states with a CARE Act, the law applies only to hospitals and hospital discharges. It does not cover rehabilitation facilities, nursing homes, or outpatient clinics.

The law also does not force the hospital to provide ongoing support after discharge. Once the training is done and the patient leaves, responsibility for care moves to the family and any home health agencies involved. The CARE Act does not set standards for the quality of training or guarantee that the named caregiver can always be present.

Medicare's discharge planning rule and your right to a written plan

If your parent is covered by Medicare, hospital discharge planning is governed by specific federal rules. Every Medicare-participating hospital must offer discharge planning to all inpatients. This is not just a summary at the end of a hospital stay. The planning must begin early, often within the first day or two after admission.

The process involves an assessment of the patient's likely needs after leaving the hospital. This can cover everything from medication changes to physical therapy, equipment, and transportation. The key is that the hospital must provide a written discharge plan. This document should list diagnoses, medication instructions, necessary follow-up appointments, and what to do if problems arise.

A family caregiver, especially if named under a CARE Act, has the right to participate in these discussions. You can ask for a copy of the plan and request changes if something does not make sense or seems unsafe. The nurse or social worker must also explain the plan in a way that you understand, not just in technical terms meant for another clinician.

Keep reading: What Medicare's GUIDE Model Means for Dementia Caregivers

The Important Message from Medicare and its two notice windows

Every Medicare patient admitted to the hospital receives a document called the Important Message from Medicare, often shortened to "the IM." This two-page notice spells out the patient's rights, including the right to appeal a discharge decision. The hospital is required to deliver the IM within two days of admission and again no later than two days before discharge.

If a patient's stay is unexpectedly short, the second copy may be presented on the day of discharge itself. The IM is not just paperwork. It triggers timelines for appeals and lays out who to contact if you disagree with the discharge. The form must be explained to the patient or their representative, and you can ask for clarification before signing.

You do not have to sign the IM if you disagree with the discharge. Signing only confirms receipt, not agreement. If you feel the discharge is too soon or unsafe, you can use the appeal instructions printed on the form, which leads directly to the next step in the process.

How a fast appeal through the BFCC-QIO actually works

If you want to challenge a Medicare discharge, you can file a fast appeal with an organization known as the Beneficiary and Family Centered Care Quality Improvement Organization, or BFCC-QIO. Every region has one, and the phone number appears on the Important Message from Medicare.

Here is how the process works. You must call the BFCC-QIO before the discharge date listed on the IM. Once you contact them, the hospital must hold off on discharging your parent until the QIO completes its review, usually within one day.

The QIO will ask for the hospital's discharge plan, the medical record, and your reason for appealing. You may submit your own statement or additional evidence. The decision is made quickly, often by the next calendar day. If the QIO agrees with you, the hospital must continue care and rework the discharge plan. If the QIO sides with the hospital, the patient may be discharged, but you can request a further review.

During the appeal, Medicare continues to pay for the hospital stay. If you miss the deadline, you can still appeal, but your parent may have to leave the hospital while the appeal is pending. For the fastest response, call as soon as you receive the IM and believe discharge is not appropriate.

See how CareCircleLog handles this for senior and family caregiving

Observation status, the MOON notice and the three midnight rule for rehab

Not every hospital stay is classified as an inpatient admission. Sometimes, a patient is kept for "observation status," which can last for one or more nights on the same hospital floor. Observation status does not count toward the inpatient days needed for Medicare to pay for skilled nursing or rehab in a facility.

Hospitals must inform patients of observation status with a form called the Medicare Outpatient Observation Notice, or MOON. The MOON must explain that although your parent is in a hospital bed, Medicare considers them an outpatient for billing purposes. This affects what Medicare covers after discharge.

For Medicare to pay for a stay in a skilled nursing facility, the patient must have three consecutive inpatient midnights. Time spent under observation does not count, even if care looks the same. If your parent is transferred to rehab after two nights of observation and one night as an inpatient, Medicare will usually deny payment for the rehab stay.

Always ask the discharge planner whether your parent has met the three inpatient midnight rule if rehab is being considered. The difference can mean thousands of dollars in out-of-pocket costs or a denied claim later.

Skilled nursing coverage denials and the notice that starts the clock

When Medicare or an insurer plans to stop paying for skilled nursing care, the facility must give you written notice. This is often called a Notice of Medicare Non-Coverage, or NOMNC. The notice tells you when coverage will end and how to appeal the decision.

Once you receive the NOMNC, you must act quickly if you wish to appeal. The deadline is usually noon the day before coverage is set to end. Filing an appeal means the facility must continue care while an independent reviewer decides if your parent is still eligible for Medicare coverage.

You can submit statements from doctors, therapists, or your own observations about your parent's condition. The reviewer will consider whether your parent still needs skilled care, not just custodial help. The window for action is short, and missing the deadline can mean stopping skilled care or paying privately.

What to write down while the discharge nurse is still in the room

Discharge can be a confusing and stressful moment, even for experienced caregivers. While the nurse or case manager is present, take the opportunity to clarify every step. Do not rely on memory or on a packet of handouts alone.

• Ask for a copy of the full written discharge plan. Check that it lists all diagnoses, medications, and follow-up appointments.
• Write down the names and direct phone numbers of the discharge planner, nurse, and any home health contacts.
• Confirm if your parent was admitted as an inpatient or kept on observation status. Note the dates and ask if the three midnight rule is met for rehab coverage.
• If your parent needs equipment or services at home, get the order in writing and ask when it will be delivered.
• If the hospital gives you a notice such as the Important Message from Medicare or a MOON notice, jot down when you received it and any appeal deadlines.
• Ask for a demonstration of any home care you are expected to provide, and write down the steps. If you are unsure, request a repeat demonstration.
• Document who will handle medication management, transportation, and appointments in the first week after discharge.

After discharge, family communication often breaks down when the plan is not shared or details are forgotten. A shared log for medications, appointments, visit notes, and rotating duties can help keep everyone on the same page, especially when multiple relatives are involved. Tools that track updates and responsibilities in one place support compliance and reduce stress when your parent comes home.